Skip to content
Archery Care

Mathews Arrow Web HD 6-Arrow vs TightSpot 5-Arrow

A spec-by-spec, CareScore™-driven breakdown of these two bow quivers. Every metric is normalised and weighted so the winner is decided by the data.

The verdict

Winner: the Mathews Arrow Web HD 6-ArrowCareScore 97.0 vs 63.8.

The Mathews Arrow Web HD 6-Arrow takes this matchup with a CareScore of 97.0, a 33.2-point margin over the TightSpot 5-Arrow. It pulls ahead most on arrow capacity and street price. That said, the better buy still depends on how you shoot — check the spec table below for the trade-offs.

Archery Care
HEAD-TO-HEAD · BOW QUIVERS
👑 WINNER
Mathews Arrow Web HD 6-Arrow
Mathews
Arrow Web HD 6-Arrow
97
CARESCORE™
$169.99
TightSpot 5-Arrow
TightSpot
5-Arrow
64
CARESCORE™
$189.95
VS
SpecMathews Arrow Web HD 6-ArrowTightSpot 5-Arrow
Street Price$169.99$189.95
Arrow Capacity65
Weight9.90 oz
MountOne-pieceOne-piece
OEM FitUniversalUniversal
Hood(ref)Foam-insertVented
Hand(ref)BothBoth
Length(ref)
Material(ref)Carbon-aluminum
Detachable(ref)YesYes
Specs won20
CareScore97.063.8

More bow quivers comparisons