Skip to content
Archery Care

Broadheads · Ranked by CareScore™

Best Broadheads for Elk

An elk shoulder is where thin blades go to die. Penetration rules this list: blade thickness and ferrule strength are weighted far above cut size, and heavy grain options matter for high-momentum arrow builds.

Who this is for: Western hunters who need maximum penetration through heavy bone and thick hide.

The short answer

The best broadhead for elk & big game is the Iron Will S Series (S100) with a CareScore of 76.8/100 at $139.95, ahead of the SEVR Titanium 2.0 4-Blade Hybrid (66.6).

Ranked by the published CareScore v1.1.0 methodology with weights re-tuned for this buyer — June 2026 data.

Top Pick — Elk & Big Game

Iron Will S Series (S100)

Excellent$139.95
77
CareScore

This is the buy-once head. Iron Will grinds the blades from .062 A2 tool steel, cryo-treats and triple-tempers them to 60 HRC, then hand-checks the edges. The tanto tip is patented and the lighter heads ride a Grade 5 titanium ferrule. At $140 a three-pack you're paying five times the Muzzy tax — but these resharpen and come back season after season.

Blade
0.062"
Ferrule
Titanium
Grains
8
Price
$139.95
0.062-inch A2 tool steel blades hold an edge through bone Eight weight options from 100 to 250 grain — heavy-arrow heaven
Runner-Up

SEVR Titanium 2.0 4-Blade Hybrid

Very Good$65.97
67
CareScore

SEVR took its best-selling Ti 2.0 rear-deploy head and added a .75-inch fixed bleeder, pushing total cut past 2.75 inches. The Grade 5 titanium ferrule and Lock-and-Pivot blades carry over, so the main blades still pivot around bone instead of snapping. It's rated to 525 fps, which covers every crossbow on the market right now.

Ferrule
Titanium
Grains
2
Price
$65.97
Cut
2.00"
Pivoting main blades shrug off bone hits that fold cheaper mechanicals 525 fps crossbow rating with a true hybrid cut profile

G5 Megameat

Solid$69.95
55
CareScore

G5's big mechanical is machined entirely from stainless steel — no cast aluminum anywhere — and it shows when you hit a shoulder. Three rear-sliding blades open to a 2-inch cut, held shut in flight by the SnapLock collar. It's the mechanical for people who want Rage-sized holes with G5 build quality, and there's a crossbow-specific version in 100 and 125 grain.

Ferrule
Steel
Grains
2
Price
$69.95
Cut
2.00"
Full 2-inch cut from three blades, not two — messier wound channels 100% stainless steel body survives impacts that trash aluminum ferrules
51
CareScore

The Trypan NC is Rage's flagship two-blade, and the NC stands for the best thing about it: no collar. Finger-tab blade retention killed the shock collars that used to pop off in quivers and fail at crossbow speeds. You get a full 2-inch cut from .039 stainless blades on a one-piece titanium ferrule, and the entry holes are the kind you can fit a fist in.

Blade
0.039"
Ferrule
Titanium
Grains
1
Price
$49.99
Massive 2-inch slap-cut entry wounds that make short blood trails One-piece titanium ferrule on a sub-$50 street price
46
CareScore

The Exodus has barely changed in a decade because it hasn't needed to. The trick is geometry: the head is so compact the 1.25-inch blades tuck inside the length of a field point, so it flies like one. Three .040 stainless blades wrap a hardened steel tip that's genuinely cut-on-contact. It's the fixed head people buy after a mechanical lets them down.

Blade
0.040"
Ferrule
Steel
Grains
3
Price
$44.99
Flies closer to field points than almost any fixed head this wide Thick .040 replaceable blades take bone hits and ask for more

Muzzy Trocar

Fair$42.99
35
CareScore

The Trocar is the working-class fixed blade: one-piece stainless ferrule, three .035 blades set on a right helix, and that famous bone-splitting Trocar tip. The helical blade layout spins the arrow like fletching does, which is why this short little head groups well at distance. Nothing exotic, nothing to deploy, nothing to fail.

Blade
0.035"
Ferrule
Steel
Grains
1
Price
$42.99
Cheapest proven head in this lineup at street prices Solid one-piece stainless ferrule shrugs off shoulder blades
35
CareScore

Grim Reaper's spring-loaded front-deploy classic, with a tip that's its own weapon: three mini .015 razors locked into a hardened Trocar point, so it's cutting before the main blades even open. The standard head runs three .035 stainless blades at 1-3/8 inches, but the line sprawls — four cut sizes, four weights, plus new 4-blade Mini Mag versions.

Blade
0.035"
Ferrule
Aluminum
Grains
4
Price
$54.99
Most weight options of any mechanical here: 75 through 125 grain Spring-blade retention has no collars or bands to fuss with
29
CareScore

Four blades, 1-1/8 inch each way, 2-1/4 inches of total cut from a head shorter than your thumbnail. The Magnum's party trick is that a four-blade this compact still flies like a field point from fast compounds. The Alcatraz bladelock holds the .035 Lutz blades in a steel ferrule, and the four-edge tip splits bone instead of skating off it.

Blade
0.035"
Ferrule
Steel
Grains
2
Cut
1.13"
Four cutting edges make wider, leakier wound channels than 3-blades Super short profile keeps wind planing to a minimum

Other broadheads lists

All Broadheads reviews & comparisons